Oh wait, I'm getting everything mixed up. Let's start again.
The summer of 1992 was the first year I was allowed to attend the Mission Trip with the church youth group. I was beyond thrilled to go live in rural Georgia for a week and fix up houses of folks who couldn't afford it, while at night writing notes for my secret buddy, taking swims in the lake, and playing spades on the porch. To this day those trips burn more brightly in my memory than the numerous Florida and ski trips that often happened in those years. Writing out the details makes them seem so wholesome. And they were.
During this time I had a strange dual life, because my high school friends and acquaintances were entirely different from church friends and acquaintances. Church was probably a class above, moneywise, and exponentially whiter. Around this time, the high schoolers would often move away from pop music and 'oldies', and moving towards listening to country. Because, even though Atlanta is a big metropolitan area, it's still in the south, it's still only a 15 minutes drive to rural spaces, and these people were still white southern christians. Some trends are just bound to be followed.
But I still hated country music. And not in the typical whiney teenager way. I had reasons. I hated how the male vocalists did that yodeling with their voice and would slide all over the notes sloppily. I hated how simplistic the chord structures were (I was just learning guitar). I hated mundane the lyrics were (I had already been into Indigo Girls and other singer-songwriter types, so I had a taste for more lofty attempts at poetry in my lyrical taste). But driving around in vans in rural north Georgia, there was no argument to be made. Only 3 or 4 stations were received on the radio, and they were all country or lousy talk radio. And it seemed cruel to vote for the radio to just be off, so I let the country fans have there moment in the sun.
The was one song that came on the radio once a day I loved. "I Feel Lucky" by Chapin. I went home to my local Turtle's music store and bought the tape. My mother lightly chastised me, saying "you bought a whole album when you only know one song?" She was also skeptical of whether I would actually like a country album. Now, this criticism could have been made of a LOT of albums that I've purchased in my life, as far as the one-song rule. But it's amusing that she actually vocalized it in this case, since she became a Chapin fan, thanks to me.
So Chapin was my guilty pleasure through high school. For friends who liked Indigo Girls, I could often convince them to give her a listen, and I would often use her as middle ground to the growing rednecks in my youth group who would ride in my car to Baskin Robbins and later would avoid all together, partly because their parents bought bigger houses in whiter neighborhoods further away from the city.
Chapin's not really very country. She's just as pop as Garth Brooks. She's from DC for chrissakes. But she doesn't use her breasts like Shania Twain does. She doesn't yodel. Her chord structures are pretty simple, but I don't act as self-righteous about that anymore. Her lyrics are sometimes complex, sometimes cliche. And I haven't been able to sit through an entire album of hers since Stones in the Road.
But she can still make me cry with songs written 15 years ago. And I'd still marry her, move to the country with several big dogs and sit on rocking chairs every evening, drink whiskey or sweet tea and watch the sun go down. I'm so urban-minded it's ridiculous, but occasionally, certain people will bring out a hidden desire.